In the News
New York Times
Video of Charlotte Police Shooting Could Be the Last Released in North Carolina
Wall Street Journal
Charlotte, Tulsa Highlight Patchwork Approach to Releasing Body Camera Videos
This might be the last police video from North Carolina you'll ever see
City of Charlotte facing national criticism for not releasing videos of fatal police shooting
New York Times
North Carolina Pays a Price for Bigotry
ACLU Releases Documents Detailing Cell Phone Tracking by North Carolina Police Departments
The American Civil Liberties Union this weekend released the results of public records requests filed last August to hundreds of local police departments across the country, asking them about their policies, practices, and procedures for tracking cell phone records.
More than 40 of the police departments that responded are from North Carolina, including the counties of Alamance, Buncombe, Guilford, and New Hanover, and the cities of Asheville, Burlington, Chapel Hill, Charlotte-Mecklenburg, Fayetteville, Greenville, High Point, Raleigh, and Wilmington.
As The New York Times reported on Sunday, the records show that the practice of tracking cell phones “has become a powerful and widely used surveillance tool for local police officials, with hundreds of departments, large and small, often using it aggressively with little or no court oversight.”
Many of the approximately 200 law enforcement agencies that responded in North Carolina and around the country said they track cell phones without a warrant. In Wilson County, N.C., for example, police obtain cell phone tracking data where it is “relevant and material” to an ongoing investigation – a standard much lower than probable cause.
“These findings raise tremendous privacy concerns for individuals all across North Carolina,” said Katy Parker, Legal Director of the ACLU of North Carolina Legal Foundation. “In order to preserve Americans’ constitutional right to privacy, the government should have to obtain a warrant before tracking people’s cell phones. While the inconsistency of legal standards among different jurisdictions in North Carolina is disturbing, the fact that some agencies do obtain warrants when they have probable cause to track a cell phone shows that such a practice is both reasonable and workable.”
The ACLU supports bipartisan legislation currently pending in both the House of Representatives and the Senate that would address this problem called the Geolocation Privacy and Surveillance (GPS) Act. It would require law enforcement officers to obtain a warrant to access location information from cell phones or GPS devices. It would also mandate that private telecommunications companies obtain their customers’ consent before collecting location data.
The U.S. Supreme Court in January held in U.S. v. Jones that prolonged location tracking is a search under the Fourth Amendment, but the effects of that ruling on law enforcement have yet to be seen.
The written responses of North Carolina police departments to the ACLU’s public records request can be found online here.